Cats catch birds. Fact. Bird lovers get upset about it. Fact. However, when someone gets so upset about it he starts writing letters to local cat owners demanding they keep their cats under control, have things gone a bit too far? Nature lover defends killer cat warning.
According to some estimates, our cats kill around 55 million birds in the UK every year, which does sound like an awful lot! Interestingly however, the RSPB don’t believe cats actually have all that much effect on the overall numbers of birds in our gardens. According to them, many millions of birds die naturally every year, mainly through starvation, disease, or other forms of predation, and most hatchlings naturally die before they reach breeding age anyway. It may seem a bit harsh, but it is therefore thought likely that most of the birds killed by cats would have probably succumbed to something else anyway before the next breeding season.
Nevertheless, many people would still prefer to prevent cats, especially other people’s cats, from hunting and catching birds in their gardens, However, unlike dogs, cats are effectively recognised as having a legal ‘right to roam’ so what, if anything, can be done to stop them?
The most common options suggested are:
Let us know what you think and what, if anything, more can be done so that bird lovers don’t feel the need to resort to hate mail!
According to current scientific understanding, the domestic cat probably evolved from the African or Middle Eastern Wildcat, which can still be found roaming the deserts of Israel, Saudi Arabia, and other Middle Eastern countries today. Once some of these formerly wild felines became human companions, probably for the mutual benefit of catching vermin plaguing our own ancestors crops and food stores, they appear to have accompanied tribes migrating and spreading throughout the ancient world.
Today’s African Wildcat resembles a brown striped tabby and is slightly larger than our domestic cat, although due to frequent interbreeding with feral cats, finding a ‘pure’ African Wildcat is now quite rare. The Wildcat eats birds, rodents, insects and reptiles and is mainly active during night and twilight. African Wildcats are solitary and territorial creatures, although the home range of a male will usually overlap the home ranges of several females.
So, on the face of it, it would appear our house cat hasn’t changed all that much from its ancestors apart from being found in a much larger variety of shapes and colours these days, from slinky Siamese to fluffy Persian. Like its ancestors, the domestic cat is still largely a solitary creature that enjoys hunting similar prey during the twilight or night hours.
One other mystery is solved too. If our cats ancestors originated in the desert, no wonder every cat I’ve ever known is seemingly at his most contented when he is sprawled out in the sunshine or in front of a roaring fire!
We live in a world where everything must be done now and no one ever takes the time to switch off. Our work is all-consuming and many of us also spend long hours commuting. Even when we are at home, we are on call via our computers and our mobiles, 24/7. Somehow, we convince ourselves the world will come to an end if we don’t get everything done and, as a result, many of us are actually making ourselves ill.
Sadly, this way of life is as equally stressful for our poor cats and dogs. A lack of mental and physical stimulation, coupled with long hours home alone and a family that is always in a rush, sooner or later creates a pet that is stressed out too. It is a sad fact that one reason why so many people end up seeking dog behaviourists for their dogs or even giving dogs up for rehoming because they cannot cope with them is because they, themselves, have created the problem through their own stressed out lifestyles.
In recent years, while we have been working to improve the conditions for wild animals kept in captivity by providing a richer environment and experiences for them in animal parks, things have become significantly worse for our pets, where cats are kept permanently indoors with nothing to do and dogs are left shut up alone at home for hours, transported everywhere in the back of cars and only offered rushed walks or quick games in local parks, where the aim is just to get the ‘duty’ of exercising the dog over and done with as quickly as possible in the allotted time slot. If this is the price of progress, maybe it is just a little too high?
When I was a kid, the cat spent his days climbing trees in the back garden or chasing mice under the laurel bushes. The dog spent the morning ‘helping’ Mum with the chores and, in the afternoon, they went for a long walk together across the fields, before walking to meet us kids from school, followed by a great romp together in the back garden before tea.
Too much rushing around helps no one. So, next time you are about to lose your cool because the cat has shredded the loo roll or, mobile phone glued to one ear, you are screaming at the dog to get back in the car because it’s time to go – stop, close your eyes and take a deep breath. Then ask yourself this: if you’ve allowed yourself to become that stressed, is it any wonder your poor pet is climbing the walls too?
Many thanks to all of you who took part in our recent poll about reactive dogs, the results of which were very interesting. The majority of those who voted felt that owners just allowing their dogs to run up to other dogs was the biggest contributor to an increase in reactive dogs. I think this result is great news because the more this message gets around, the more quickly we may be able to put a stop to what is undoubtedly one of the biggest causes of fights between dogs and even their humans. A simple code of conduct where owners automatically called their dogs back and put them on leads when first meeting other owners and dogs would, in my opinion, make a huge difference for the better for everyone.
Many of you also felt that nervous owners create nervous, reactive dogs, and that incorrect socialisation as puppies, a lack of proper regular exercise and even chemical additives in food and environment were major contributors too. I would totally agree with you on all these points and, as someone who knows only too well how harmful man-made chemicals can be for humans, I was very pleased that people are beginning to think about this with regards to their pets too.
I was also very pleased to see many of you selecting incorrect socialisation, because I am convinced that getting it wrong can actually sometimes do more harm than not doing it at all. Everyone now seems have got the message that early socialisation is essential, but so many seem to think this just means taking your puppy to the nearest park and leaving him to ‘play’ with any other dogs that might be around, while the owners stand around chatting.
Unfortunately, this can so easily end up with your pup learning all the wrong lessons, like just running straight up to any or all other dogs, regardless of how the other dog is responding. It also increases the chances of your pup being bullied and may even contribute to him becoming a bully himself as he gets bigger. If you pup was bred responsibly, his Mum will have already taught him the basics in dog/dog interaction. The last thing we want is to undo all her good work by encouraging him to behave badly in the local dog park!
I saw a tweet recently from someone claiming that the number of dogs whose owners describe them as ‘dog-reactive’ or even dog aggressive now seem to be almost the same as the number who get on fine with most other dogs they meet. I’m not sure if this is true or not but I do know that we seem to have more problems than ever before.
We’ve come up with a list of all the reasons/excuses we’ve seen given for why some dogs are ‘reactive’ and we’d really love to know what you think. Please select all that seem relevant to you:
Many of you probably watched the Channel 4 documentary – Dogs: Their Secret Lives – last Tuesday. How many of you, like me, were not actually very surprised at the large number of dogs in the study that were found to be less than totally comfortable with being ‘home alone’ day after day?
After all, unlike cats, dogs are social animals and would rarely be found living alone naturally. Also, unlike cats, dogs do not normally spend at least 16 out of every 24 hours sleeping so, for us to expect our dogs to sleep all night while we do, and then to sleep all day while we go out to work, is a little unrealistic!
There was some great advice on how to prevent and/or help dogs overcome separation anxiety, but I was amazed nothing was said about how much exercise these dogs were – or were not – getting before they were left alone. After all, a tired dog is much more likely to settle down to rest than one which is so full of pent up energy that he’s already bouncing off the walls before the owners are even out the door!
If the majority of the dogs in this study were only being left for 3-4 hours per day, I suspect they are actually among the luckier ones. I am pretty sure that there are hundreds, if not thousands, of dogs that are regularly left for 8 or more hours day after day, often with little more than a quick run down the garden or walk round the block before they are left. No wonder so many of our dogs are going stir crazy!
Finally, what do people feel about the idea of selectively breeding dogs that are better able to cope with being left for hours? On the face of it, that sounds reasonable, doesn’t it? After all, no one likes to think of their poor dog pacing and howling for hours on end so, if anything can be done to breed dogs that are less anxious generally, that has to be a good thing, right? Then I got to thinking that surely one of the things we love about our dogs is how much they seem to love being with us too? Is it possible that, if we were to deliberately breed for dogs that didn’t mind being left alone, we might actually eventually lose part of what makes a dog a dog? After all, if you want a pet that really doesn’t mind whether you have to go out to work all day or not, you can always get a cat!